UF damages its reputation by restricting academic freedom
By silencing its academics for political reasons, the University of Florida is rapidly destroying the reputation it has worked so long and so hard to forge.
Recent reports have revealed that the UF has barred several faculty members from testifying in court cases against the state since last year. In their awkward response to the controversy that followed, university officials failed to coherently explain their policies and address concerns they ceded to political pressure from Governor Ron DeSantis.
The New York Times first reported that UF officials banned three professors from testifying in a case challenging a state election law because the university is a state institution and that would be ” contrary to the interests of the UF ”. A UF spokeswoman later told The Sun that professors would be allowed to act as witnesses, as long as they were not paid and using university resources or time.
But a later report from the Miami Herald / Tampa Bay Times Tallahassee Bureau showed that the university imposed various restrictions on other faculty that prevented them from testifying, in cases involving the state’s ban on mask warrants and the ban. to vote for former criminals. The story documented shifting politics, with the only consistent factor being that the UF prevented professors from challenging the measures championed by DeSantis and the Republican-controlled legislature.
More editorials from Sun:
A flawed process should not prevent the rezoning of St. Michael’s property
Promote water conservation before constructing expensive pipelines
Matt Howland is the best choice for the City of Gainesville Commission
UF restricts the freedom of expression and academic freedom of its professors, who are supposed to allow professors to conduct research and express their opinions without political interference or reprisals. The actions conflict with what is permitted at other public universities as well as with UF’s past practices, which not only authorized but celebrated its professors for their participation in legal matters of public importance.
So what has changed? UF administrators appear to be afraid of angering DeSantis, who has offered to cut funding to universities deemed too leftist and inclined to attack anyone who challenges his power. Public schools in Alachua County and other school districts have learned this lesson the hard way, after suffering a cut in funding amid a dispute over mask mandates.
US News and World Report ranked UF among the top five public universities in the country for the first time this fall, in part thanks to state funding that helped UF hire hundreds of new faculty members. By trying to circulate the money, UF officials are causing untold damage to the reputation of UF, which attracts faculty and students while taking rankings into account.
The controversy is just the latest example of UF demeaning to stay in the governor’s good graces. UF President Kent Fuchs had previously backed down on COVID-19 protections to follow DeSantis’ opposition to such measures. Administrators also stepped up the hiring of Dr. Joseph Ladapo to UF faculty, paving the way for DeSantis to appoint the mask and vaccine skeptic as Florida’s surgeon general.
UF begins to reap the consequences. UF’s accreditation body has launched an investigation into whether preventing professors from testifying violates its standards. The Senate of the Faculty of UF launches inquiries. Democrats in Congress have called for hearings. A Palm Beach County commissioner has suggested suspending a land deal for a UF campus there.
Fuchs must establish a new policy that genuinely protects academic freedom rather than showing loyalty to the governor. And he better do it quickly, otherwise UF will spend a lot more time trying to fix its reputation.
Join the conversation
Send a letter to the editor (up to 200 words) to [email protected] Letters should include the author’s full name and city of residence. Additional guidelines for submitting longer guest letters and columns are available at bit.ly/sunopinionguidelines.
Journalism matters. Your support matters.
Get a digital subscription to the Gainesville Sun. Includes must-see content on Gainesville.com and Gatorsports.com, the latest news and updates on all your devices, and access to the Gainesville.com ePaper. Visit www.gainesville.com/subscribenow to register.